Reviews of ‘Joan of Arc’ by Helen Castor


(c) Faber & Faber

(c) Faber & Faber


Joan of Arc: a History by Helen Castor, review: ‘popular history at its best’ by Diarmaid MacCulloch – The Telegraph

Joan of Arc: A History, by Helen Castor by Rachel Moss – Times Higher Education

‘In this sober, serious and compelling account Helen Castor… succeeds triumphantly in rescuing her from the various strait jackets…in which she has been confined.’ – The Sunday Times Culture 28th September 2014

‘In this fascinating biography, Helen Castor argues that familiarity with Joan’s story has led to a certain laziness, that we tend to read her story as if it were some kind of folk tale. Instead, Castor asks us to clear our preconceptions and follow Joan’s story as it unfolds, without jumping ahead to what happens next….What makes Helen Castor’s re-telling of this story so exciting is the way she sorts through the fiendishly complex medieval source material in order to locate the telling detail.’ – Event Magazine (Mail on Sunday) 26 October 2014

Joan of Arc by Helen Castor review – a triumph of history by Janet Nelson – The Guardian

Maid of Orléans is superbly brought to life in flesh-and-blood tale by Kate Mosse – The Evening Standard

Joan of Arc: a history by Jessie Childs – The Tablet

Joan of Arc: A History review – a new window on to a strange chapter in French history by Laura Feigel – The Observer

Joan of Arc: A History by Helen Castor, book review: The truth behind France’s national icon by Jad Adams – The Independent


Posted in Book Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off on Reviews of ‘Joan of Arc’ by Helen Castor

4 November 1551


We get a glimpse of Lady Jane Grey on the 4th of November 1551 when Edward VI entertained Mary of Guise at the Palace of Westminster.

Edward recorded the details in his diary.


4th November

‘The Duke of Suffolk and the Lord Fitzwalter, the Lord Braye and many other lords and gentlemen accompanied by Suffolk’s wife, the Lady Frances, the Lady Margaret [Douglas], the Duchess of Richmond and of Northumberland, the Lady Jane, daughter to the Duke of Suffolk, the marchionesses of Northampton and Winchester, the countesses of Arundel, Bedford, Huntingdon and Rutland, with 100 other ladies and gentlewomen, went to the dowager and brought her through London to Westminster.’

p.44, England’s Boy King: The Diary of Edward VI, 1547-1553
edited by Jonathan North


An example of Edward’s diary.

A page from Edward VI's diary (c) British Library

A page from Edward VI’s diary
(c) British Library


Posted in On this day | Comments Off on 4 November 1551

My guest article at On The Tudor Trail…


You can read my guest article about Lady Jane’s appearance at On The Tudor Trail.

Lady Jane Grey’s Appearance


This is the fourth in my series ‘Another look at…’, which have investigated what the discovery of two letters by Dr Stephan Edwards have added to our knowledge of Lady Jane Grey.

You can read the other articles here:

Another look at…the wedding of Lady Jane

Another look at…10th July 1553

Another look at…19th July 1553


Posted in Another look at, Lady Jane Grey | Tagged | Comments Off on My guest article at On The Tudor Trail…

A look at how the Streatham portrait has been displayed over the years…


(c) NPG 6804; Lady Jane Dudley (nee Grey) by Unknown artist

(c) NPG 6804; Lady Jane Dudley (nee Grey) by Unknown artist


The portrait was discovered at a house in Streatham in January 2006. It was announced in the November of that year, that it had been purchased by the National Portrait Gallery.

The portrait was first on display at the Gallery in Room 3 of the Tudor Galleries from spring 2007 to April 2009 and then at the entrance to the ‘Lady Jane Grey’ display from December 2009 until 15th August 2010. Between March 2013 and May 2014 it was on display at Montacute House in Somerset.

It was back in Room 3 at the National Portrait Gallery as part of ‘The Real Tudors: Kings & Queens Rediscovered’ exhibition from 12 September 2014 until 1st March 2015.

On March 23rd, the National Portrait Gallery posted a photo of the portrait being reframed as part of Museum Week.


The portrait returned to Room 2 of Montacute House in the late spring of 2015.



The painting was the subject of a gallery talk by Justin Nolan on June 12th 2007.

These were the main points from this talk:

‘The NPG has been aware of this painting since 1923. It is a ¾ length portrait of a woman wearing high status clothing from the 1550s.

The sitter is someone of importance. Analysis (including ‘dendrochronology’) has shown that the wood used dates from after 1593. The question is why would someone paint a portrait of a woman after 1593 wearing clothing from forty years before? There must have been something about the sitter to make it worthwhile.

The inscription dates from the same time as the portrait and cross referencing it with the known ‘Lady Jayne’s’ at the time, shows that it could refer to Jane Grey.

Jane was in the public consciousness in 1602. This is shown by Thomas Dekker’s play, ‘Sir Thomas Wyatt’. Some of this play survives and in it, Jane and Guildford are portrayed as lovers. So from very early on, the romantic notion of Lady Jane Grey existed.

It is possible that this painting belonged in the collection of a gentleman who wanted to promote his enthusiasm for Protestantism and could have been part of a series of paintings of ‘Protestant Worthies.’

This was probably not intended to be an accurate portrait of Jane but was using her as a badge of the Elizabethan Protestant Order.’

There isn’t anything in this portrait that supports an accurate representation, however, the question remains, why else produce this painting’ (Justin Nolan, NPG)



The painting was displayed between 2007 and 2009 as:

‘Memorial Portrait of Lady Jane Grey (Lady Jayne)
Unknown
16th century’ (NPG)


The postcard on sale at the time had the following information:

‘Lady Jane Dudley (nee Grey) 1537-54
After a portrait by Hans Holbein the Younger.’ (NPG)


It was displayed between December 2009 and August 2010 as:

‘Unknown, 1590s

‘This panel is one of the earliest surviving portraits of England’s shortest reigning monarch Lady Jane Grey. It was not painted from life or indeed made during her lifetime. It is a commemorative portrait made at least 40 years after her death.’ (NPG)


It was displayed between March 2013 and May 2014 as:

Room 2 - The Court of Henry VIII, Montacute House

Room 2 – The Court of Henry VIII, Montacute House


‘Lady Jane Grey
By an unknown artist
Oil on oak panel 1590s’

‘This is one of the earliest surviving portraits of England’s shortest-reigning monarch, Lady Jane Grey, despite being made some 40 years after her death. The sixteen-year-old Jane Dudley (née Grey) was nominated by her cousin, Edward VI, to succeed him and at his death was uncrowned Queen of England for nine days before being deposed and executed by Mary I.

A commemorative portrait, this panel may have formed part of a set of Protestant martyrs. Scratched lines across the eyes and mouth suggest that the painting may have been subjected to an iconoclastic attack at some point in its history.’ (Montacute House)


At ‘The Real Tudors: Kings & Queens Rediscovered’ exhibition from 12 September 2014 to 1st March 2015 it was displayed as:



‘Lady Jane Grey
By an unknown artist
Oil on panel, late sixteenth century’ (NPG)

‘Lady Jane Grey was named as heir to the throne by her cousin Edward VI: however, she was imprisoned after only nine days’ rule when Mary successfully asserted her right to the crown. Highly educated and devoutly Protestant, it was only during Elizabeth’s reign that she became more widely known. This fuelled an interest in her portraiture and portraits such as this example were created to mark her place for an Elizabethan audience. However, no lifetime portraits of Jane appear to survive and it is possible that none were ever painted. By 1620, one image had gained credence as a lifetime portrait and was used as the basis for an engraving. However, the sitter in this image wears a jewel that is very similar to one that belonged to Katherine Parr, and may be Henry VIII’s sixth queen.’ (NPG)

In the catalogue to accompany the exhibition, it is stated that:

‘Even during the uncertain time between Edward’s death and Mary’s accession, Jane made little mark on contemporary commentators, and given the short period of her reign it is not likely that a portrait was ever produced.

…Numerous portraits have been identified as Jane, but no certain image during her lifetime appears to have survived, if one ever existed. One portrait thought to depict Jane was painted in the Elizabethan period and was probably produced in response to her growing reputation as a Protestant martyr. In this three-quarter-length image, she stands holding a book, wearing a costly, if simply painted, gown of red velvet and cloth-of-gold and silver. Tree-ring dating suggests that the portrait was painted in the 1590s, and thus it may derive from an earlier likeness, or could even have been adapted from a portrait of another sitter. Whatever the case, it is clear that the portrait served as a likeness of Jane for its Elizabethan audience. The fragmentary inscription, which identifies the sitter as ‘Lady Jayne’, suggests that it may have formed part of a set of portraits, and the scratched lines across the eyes and mouth may be result of a deliberate attack at some point in history.’ (1)


In May 2014, Dr Stephan Edwards published his latest findings on the portrait, at his website, Some Grey Matter. He wrote:

‘On the whole, it seems entirely likely that the Streatham Portrait was based upon some earlier reference image that depicted Katherine Parr but, like the Norris Portrait, was adapted to “become” Jane Grey in the absence of an accessible authentic portrait of Jane.’ (2)

In 2015, the portrait was included in his book ‘A Queen of a New Invention: Portraits of Lady Jane Grey Dudley, England’s ‘Nine Days Queen.’


It was displayed from late spring 2015 in Room 2 at Montacute House as:

‘Lady Jane Grey 1537 – 1554
Oil on oak panel,
c.1590 – 1600’

‘Purchased with help from the proceeds of the 150th anniversary gala.’ (Montacute House)


Sources

1.Bolland, C. and Cooper, T. (2014) The Real Tudors: Kings and Queens Rediscovered, National Portrait Gallery Publications, p.99

2.Edwards,S. Some Grey Matter – The Streatham Portrait Date accessed: 5 October 2014



Posted in Lady Jane Grey, Portraits | Tagged , , | Comments Off on A look at how the Streatham portrait has been displayed over the years…

Books 2014 – On sale today…


2 October – Joan of Arc by Helen Castor


(c) Faber & Faber

(c) Faber & Faber


‘Acclaimed historian Helen Castor brings us afresh a gripping life of Joan of Arc. Instead of the icon, she gives us a living, breathing young woman; a roaring girl fighting the English, and taking sides in a bloody civil war that was tearing fifteenth century France apart.

Here is a portrait of a 19-year-old peasant who hears voices from God; a teenager transformed into a warrior leading an army to victory, in an age that believed women should not fight. And it is also the story behind the myth we all know, a myth which began to take hold at her trial: that of the Maid of Orleans, the saviour of France, a young woman burned at the stake as a heretic, a woman who five hundred years later would be declared a saint.

Joan and her world are brought vividly to life in this refreshing new take on the medieval world. Helen Castor brings us to the heart of the action, to a woman and a country in turmoil, a world where no-one – not Joan herself, nor the people around her, princes, bishops, soldiers or peasants – knew what would happen next.’

From Amazon.co.uk

Helen Castor

Further details – Amazon.co.uk


Posted in Books 2014 | Tagged | Comments Off on Books 2014 – On sale today…